Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen [2022]- Compared

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen [2022]- Compared

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen [2022]- Compared

Due to the big tech brands dominating the stylus market, the advancement of stylus technology has skyrocketed and so many innovative functionalities have been introduced.

As a result, stylus pens are slowly replacing digital pen displays and workstations of many digital artists.

Ask any tech enthusiast for a recommendation for a good stylus pen, and the two main answers you receive will be the Apple Pencil and the Samsung S-Pen

They are well deserving of such recommendations too, due to their sheer dominance in their respective markets.

Samsung S-Pen relies on its vast experience with stylus making since the early note lineup days, while Apple Pencil relies on its brand value and technology prowess.

Personally, I own both an Apple Pencil and an S-Pen and I am constantly flooded with questions regarding which is the best overall stylus pen.

Well, I seek to put an end to that and compare both the Samsung S-Pen and Apple Pencil and see who comes out on top: Experience or Tech prowess.

Ultimately debate of the Apple Pen vs Samsung S-Pen exclusively depends on the operating system - iOS or Android - the pen is being used on. But judging purely on capabilities, Apple Pencil has great software support and reliable hardware. But the extra features and compatibility that the S-Pen provides give it a very slight edge over the Apple Pencil.

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen: Design and Aesthetics

Design and Aesthetics

Aesthetics is a key area to consider when you are in the market for a stylus pen. The in-hand feel, weight, and material of the product make a huge impact on its utility.

Apple Pencil

Apple Pencil has a cylindrical pump design with a matte white finish all around that gives it a rather majestic feel and look.

Although the 1st generation Apple Pencil had a fully rounded design, the 2nd Gen fixed that issue with a flat side that provides better grip and doesn't roll off the table.

The first generation also had a cap on the other end that housed the poorly implemented charging port.

The 2nd generation replaced that design with magnetic charging on its flat side, thus making it much sleeker and easier to charge.

The tip is also a blunt tip that prioritizes touch sensitivity and is perfect for sketching.

Samsung S-Pen

Although Samsung has multiple models in its S-Pen range, most of the aesthetics try to be consistent.

It features a rather glossy body slightly smaller than the Apple Pencil, splashed with a rainbow of colours with respect to its parent phone/tablet body.

Their S-Pen for their Note series (and more recently their foldable lineup) also has a spring-loaded cap bottom that locks itself securely inside its dedicated phone slot.

The tip is more pointy compared to Apple Pencils and hence, is more accurate by hardware.

Verdict

Design is always a personal preference, and if you ask me I slightly prefer the Samsung S-Pen over the Apple Pencil in this area.

Samsung S-Pen is a bit handier and feels much like a pen or pencil, while the Apple Pencil can be a bit too thin for me at times.

Just recently, I did my research and wrote a comprehensive guide on Apple Pencil vs other styluses. This might give you a different perspective on the Apple Pencil.

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen: Performance

Performance

Depending on your utility with the stylus pen, there will be a certain performance benchmark that you might need to judge by.

Performance is also seriously impacted by the operating system and software they use to register the touch input.

Apple Pencil

Although Apple doesn't disclose its specs, by user experience it's safe to say it is one of the best performing AES-based stylus in the market right now.

It has great pressure sensitivity, very low latency at just 9ms, and has a very good natural palm rejection.

Although there is a slight reported issue with parallax errors, it is barely noticeable at all and I wouldn't consider it a deal-breaker at all.

iOS has also vastly adapted to the Apple Pencil and hence provides a much more integrated and seamless experience.

Samsung S-Pen

Samsung has done a great job in relating as close of performance as Apple has done, without having remotely as much freedom with its software.

Samsung S-Pen also boasts great pressure sensitivity with 4096 levels (which I assume is the same with Apple Pencil too) and has the same latency numbers at 9ms too.

S-Pen also doesn't suffer from that great of a parallax error issue as Apple, which was already negligible.

These parallax errors are more to be blamed on the smart device touchscreen rather than the pen used to input touch information.

But unfortunately, Android is still not that great with stylus features and hence Samsung has to do extra work to make everything perfect, and you can only do so much.

Verdict

Both are very similar in terms of the performance offered, but the software experience for stylus pens on iOS/iPadOS is far better than any android skin in the market right now.

For that specific reason, I would go with the Apple Pencil for sure.

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen: Features and Connectivity

Features and Connectivity

Stylus pens usually improve upon their USP status by including features that appeal to a broader range of the audience for maximum sales.

This also requires them to have solid connectivity functionalities to pair with the broader audience with different smart devices.

Apple Pencil

Apple pencil incorporates only the bare necessary features, such as palm rejection, tip-tilt shading, etc.

It relies mostly on the iOS software for most of its extra functionality and features.

Connectivity is great with iPads as it automatically connects to the device when you detach the pen from the magnetic charging side of the iPad.

But compatibility is a whole another issue, as Apple Pencil is only supported by select models of the iPad lineup. It won't work with android or any other operating system.

Samsung S-Pen

Samsung S-Pen is completely different from what Apple has done, in that it is loaded with a bunch of features.

S-Pen has dedicated shortcut buttons that can be custom configured for multiple use cases.

It has a lot of gestures supported, and the sole reason it has a battery is to juice up for the extra functionality it boasts.

Connectivity is also great as it automatically connects to the Samsung device. It additionally also has Bluetooth for other devices.

This helps incompatibility with both iOS(with restricted features) and other Android devices without issues.

Verdict

This is an easy choice in Samsung S-Pen.

Even if Apple adds more gestures and device support, chances are it will be from their next-gen Pencils and the current-gen won't notice the benefits.

If you are using the S-Pen with a Galaxy A series tablet, you can find some great alternatives to the S-Pen here- Best Styluses for galaxy Tab A series.

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen: Battery and Pricing

Battery and Pricing

Battery life is very important when considering any active stylus pen. Thankfully, newer gen stylus pens excel in battery life with respect to continuous usage.

Apple Pencil

Apple pencil lasts a very long time from a full charge. It is rated for 12 hours of use and Apple's battery stats are always real-life stats and in my usage stands true to itself.

It also supports fast charging and fills up the pen in just 15 minutes.

Charging is also very convenient by just magnetically attaching the pencil on the side of the iPad Pro. This helps in making the battery life just a non-factor in general.

The Apple Pencil is priced at a heft $99 for the 2nd gen and $79 for the 1st gen.

This is a high premium to pay for a stylus pen, considering third parties are available at half the price of these.

But then again, they don't offer the same functionality and features as the official Apple Pencil, so I guess the pricing is justified as per the brand.

Samsung S-Pen

Samsung pens are also fantastic with their battery management.

The phone lineup of S-Pens still work on their respective device, even if they are devoid of charge (only the extra features will be shut down)

The recent pro lineup of S-Pen boasts 16 days of battery life on normal use, with a full charge taking 50 minutes.

They also conveniently attach magnetically to charge, and also have an additional USB c port, making charging much of an afterthought, just like the Pencil.

The price of S-Pens varies across devices, from as much as $99 for their S Pen Pro to as little as $30 for their note series S-Pens.

Verdict

Although battery charging speeds are technically better on the Apple Pencil, Samsung does keep up with Apple by earning points lasting 10x longer than the Pencil.

The pricing is also a similar affair, but considering Samsung's extra features, the S-Pen does take the cake in this category.

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen: Miscellaneous Specifications

Miscellaneous Specifications

There is a lot more stuff regarding a stylus pen to look at, especially while comparing two different products.

I have made a simple chart for easy understanding that I feel will help greatly differentiate between the two products while refreshing the information we have learnt.

For the sake of proper and accurate classification, I will be comparing the Apple Pencil 2nd gen with the Samsung S Pen Pro.

Features Apple PencilSamsung S-Pen
Body materialPlastic; matte finishPlastic; glossy finish
TipBlunt; Made of soft rubberPointy; Made of Plastic
Weight20.7g14g
ConnectivityBluetooth (restricted to supported devices)Bluetooth
Pressure levels4096Not specified, but judging by usage it should be 4096
Palm rejectionSupportedSupported
Tip tiltingSupportedSupported
Initial Activation Force (IAF)0g0g; higher on older stylus pens
LatencyVery lowBit higher comparatively
Response timeGreat, considering iPad Pro's 120Hz display refresh and 240Hz touch samplingSpectacular, considering Galaxy Tab S7+'s 120Hz display refresh and 360Hz touch sampling
Touch trackingGreat, due to 3ms responseGood, due to 9ms response
Charging implementationsAttaches magnetically to iPad Pro to chargeCan attach magnetically to tab S7+, can also charge with the inbuilt USB-C port
Charging time for a full charge15 minutes50 minutes
Battery life and standby12 hours of continuous use16 days standby with 1-hour use per day
Dedicated custom buttonsNoOne
Gesture controlsRestricted gestures with respect to the app in useYes; can be used to trigger various tasks such as controlling apps and using the pen as a shutter button while taking pictures amongst many things.
Hardware Compatibility Only compatible with select iPad models.Compatible with a wide range of galaxy products, as well as restricted compatibility with iOS and Android devices
Software Compatibility Features compatible across a wide range of Apple apps and pro-grade toolsFeatures are compatible mostly with only Galaxy apps.
Pricing$99$99
Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen: Final Verdict

Apple Pencil vs Samsung S-Pen : Final Verdict

Apple Pencil and the S-pen trade blows spectacularly with each other in all the categories we analyzed them in.

This shows the sheer competition amongst the brands in the market, hoping to one-up every time they get the opportunity.

By sales figures, Apple Pencil beats the S-Pen by a whole mile and some. But S-Pens has more users than the Apple Pencil.

But Apple selling the Pencil as an extra peripheral rather than the pen being with the device, like Samsung does, could be the reason for such figures.

They are the best when it comes to the operating systems they natively are compatible with, and this could be the point of contention of what your preference could be.

By in my personal opinion, I would give the Samsung S-Pen a very slight edge just due to its compatibility, features, and design aesthetics implemented.

I hope this article gave you a proper insight on the differences to make out your best decision too when it comes to the Pencil vs S-pen debate.

Have a good day!

Frequently Asked Questions(FAQs)

How long will an Apple Pencil tip last?

Depending on how much and how long you use the Apple Pencil, it will last at least 4 to 6 months.

Do Apple Pencils work on iPhones?

As of 2022, Apple pencils are restricted to be used only on select iPad Pro models. Support for iPhones is only rumoured with the 3rd generation Apple Pencils.

Can I use a completely discharged Samsung S-Pen as a Passive Stylus for drawing?

S-Pens on the note and fold lineup will work on their respective supported screens with only certain gesture features disabled if the pen doesn't have any charge.

You May Also Enjoy Reading

About Doug Stevenson

Hey! I'm Doug, My passion for tech started by fixing phones and computers for my friends and family. I worked in several technology companies and startups in the bay area after graduating from Santa Clara University. I currently work as a consultant for startups and tech companies.

I started Blinqblinq to give reliable tech advice to anyone who needs it, for free! If you have questions on anything tech-related, feel free to contact me.

DIY Profile
Doug Stevenson

Hey! I'm Doug, My passion for tech started by fixing phones and computers for my friends and family. I worked in several technology companies and startups in the bay area after graduating from Santa Clara University. I currently work as a consultant for startups and tech companies.

I started Blinqblinq to give reliable tech advice to anyone who needs it, for free! If you have questions on anything tech-related, feel free to contact me.

Connect With Me
Thanks for signing up.
Some error occured. Please try again.

Comments

The comments are closed.